1600 NE 1st Ave, Miami, FL 33132 Wed–Sat from 6PM 786-807-8587

Rum Tasting for Two in Miami: A Date Night Plan

Published · By Kaona Room

If you're searching for a rum tasting for two in Miami, most of what turns up is a daytime walking tour or a ticketed festival. That's fine if you want a crowd. If you'd rather sit somewhere dark and quiet with the person across from you, a glass in front of each of you and a bartender explaining what's in it, the better move is to book a table at Kaona Room, our 45-seat tiki speakeasy hidden inside The Leinster in Edgewater, and taste your way through the rum cocktails together.

Here's how two people can turn our cocktail menu into a proper rum tasting date without guessing.

How a rum tasting for two works at Kaona Room

Our menu is built on a collection of more than 50 rums, and most of the cocktails tell you exactly which rums are inside. That makes it easy to taste rum styles side by side, even without a neat pour in front of you.

The trick for a couple is simple. Don't both order the same drink. Order two that are built on different rums, taste across, and swap. The conversation writes itself, because the two of you will almost never agree on which glass is the best one. That disagreement is half the fun. One of you will love the deep, rich Guyanese rum, and the other will lean toward the grassier, brighter character of rhum from Martinique, which is distilled from fresh sugarcane juice rather than molasses.

Our pick for a first round is a pair that tastes age against youth. The Lychee Nut Daiquiri ($22) is a gentle Trader Vic classic from around 1960 with El Dorado 3 year Guyanese rum, lime, lychee and maraschino. The Sexy Colada ($21) uses El Dorado aged 5 years, with ginger, sea salt, cinnamon and Angostura. Same distillery, a couple of extra years in the barrel, and two very different drinks. For round two, try the Mai-Tai ($22), which blends Saint James Rhum Blanc from Martinique with Jamaican and Barbadian rums, against something darker later in the evening (more on that below).

Add a navy strength rum cocktail in the middle

Once you've tasted the gentler rums, the middle of the night is the time for something with more muscle. Navy strength and overproof rums show you what happens when there's real proof under the fruit, and those drinks are built to carry it.

  • Painkiller ($23): Pusser's Navy Rum drowned in coconut, pineapple and orange, topped with freshly grated nutmeg. The easy-drinking one of the three.
  • Sexy 69 ($24): our sexiest colada, made with 138 proof (69%) Planteray O.F.T.D. overproof rum. Creamy on top, with plenty of backbone under the coconut.
  • Aku Aku Lapu ($24): a 1960s recipe from Aku Aku Las Vegas with El Dorado 5, Planteray O.F.T.D. and dark Caribbean rums, homemade falernum, citrus and pineapple. A house favorite, limited to two per guest.

Ordering two different cocktails and trading sips works here too. If you'd rather share one big drink, the Rapa Nui Nui ($59) is a bowl for two filled with Caribbean rums, English gin, Spanish brandy and fresh citrus, and it turns the middle of the evening into a bit of an event.

A date night bar in Edgewater that ends on a nightcap

The room does a lot of the work. Bamboo, hand-carved tiki masks, warm amber light, a haze of dry ice and a jazz club feel make it the kind of place where two hours disappear without anyone checking a phone. We like to call it a two-hour vacation to paradise, and it plays well for a date because it's small. Forty-five seats means you can actually hear each other.

That's also why the aged rum belongs at the end. The Tropical Old Fashioned ($24) is our house Old Fashioned made with Kaona Rum Blend #3 from Guyana, Barbados and Jamaica, or with your choice of rum at market price, and it's about as good a slow nightcap as Miami offers. The Aged Mai-Tai ($24) is the other option, made with rums we age in house, and it's a fun close if you started the night on the regular Mai-Tai. Both make more sense once your palate has already learned what younger rum tastes like earlier in the night. If you're coming from dinner nearby or heading out after a show, a nightcap here is worth the trip on its own.

Getting in is part of the evening. Kaona Room has no sign. The entrance is somewhere inside The Leinster at 1600 NE 1st Ave, and we can't tell you exactly where, because finding the door is the first chapter. Give yourselves a few extra minutes to work it out together.

Booking your table for two

We're open Wednesday and Thursday from 6PM to 1AM and Friday and Saturday from 6PM to 2AM, closed Sunday through Tuesday. Walk-ins are welcome when space permits, but with only 45 seats there's no guarantee, so reserve ahead. Friday and Saturday regularly sell out, and we recommend booking at least 1-2 weeks in advance for those nights. Weeknights are usually available with a few days' notice, and honestly a Wednesday or Thursday is a lovely night for a slower, chattier tasting.

The dress code is smart casual, think tropical elegance. Hawaiian shirts are encouraged, and flip flops and athletic wear are not. Guests need to be 21 or older with a valid ID.

When you're ready, head to our reservations page, pick your date and a party of two, and you'll get an instant confirmation. Two glasses, a lot of rum to compare, and one door to find. We'll save you a seat at Kaona Room.

Visit Miami's Hidden Tiki Speakeasy

Kaona Room's hidden tiki speakeasy in Edgewater features 50+ rum expressions and craft tiki cocktails you cannot find anywhere else in the city.

Reserve Now